Enyimba Ghanaian goalkeeper Dauda Fatau had brought down Alalade for the penalty.
The visitors capitalized on an ABS defensive mix-up when Ernest Governor's back pass was picked up by Ikechukwu Ibenegbu whose pass find an unmarked Eric Frimpong who easily tapped in from a close range in the 22nd minute.
12 minute later, ABS should have doubled the lead when Adeshina Gata's another clear cut chance was fired inches away from goal by Abubakar Chindo.
Three minutes before half time, Stephen Chukwude fantastic effort was well dealt with by Yinka Adewale in goal for ABS FC.
The Saraki Boys restarted the game better than the visitors as they pegged the Peoples Elephant to their half for most parts of the 2nd half.
One minute into the restart, Chindo's pass picked up Alalade who was unmarked to head past Fatau to restore the hosts' lead.
After the ABS second goal, the game became an end to end battle with the two sides searching for more goals.
In the 58th minute, Fatau had a wrong footing to dash an incoming Alalade the ball but the ABS striker slipped to give back the ball to the Enyimba's keeper to clear for safety.
Five minutes before time, Alalade was presented with another opportunity to score his second of the game but Fatau was well positioned to catch from close range.
Speaking after the game, Henry Makinwa, said the victory was a sweet revenge to Enyimba's 3-0 win on Sunday in Calabar during a match day 34 Nigeria Professional Football League (NPFL) encounter.
"Today we played football tactically, technically, psychologically and physically to over power Enyimba.
"Going to Sunday's game, if we can beat Enyimba, we can beat Plateau United" Makinwa said.
His Enyimba counterpart, Gbenga Ogunbote, said his team paid was its complacency.
"It was an unfortunate one for us, sometimes you plan for something but you don't get it.
"We paid a high prize for complacency, the competition is the easiest way to a continental ticket" Ogunbote said
The Enyimba gaffer said there are four more games to determine a continental ticket for the Peoples Elephant. PLACE YOUR TEXT ADVERT BELOW:>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> How I Made Me =N=2.5 MILLION In 7 Days from 2 Common Product I Imported and how you can do the same. Click HERE FOR FREE Details right now Warning To Men: This 3 Foods Is Killing Your Erection. Click Here To Know Them Secret Fruits that increased my Manhood and makes me last 55 minutes+ all time - Click here to get it Warning: Got Arthritis? 3 Simple Ways To Get Cured And Be Permanently Free From Joint Pains. Click Here To See Them REVEALED!! Reduce Your Blood Sugar Level And Reverse Diabetics Within A Short Period Of Time. Click Here To See How MIDNIGHT,Pressed Mr Kilanko Suddenly Couldn't Urinate. Shrink your Enlarged Prostrate Here! Click Here Now